And the Bayesians and the frequentists shall lie down together...

Speaker: Keith Winstein , MIT CSAIL

Date: Wednesday, October 16, 2013

Time: 3:00 PM to 4:00 PM Note: all times are in the Eastern Time Zone

Refreshments: 2:45 PM

Public: Yes

Location: 32-D463 (Star)

Event Type:

Room Description:

Host: Gerald J. Sussman, MIT CSAIL

Contact: Gerald J. Sussman, 617-253-5874,

Relevant URL:

Speaker URL: None

Speaker Photo:

Reminders to:,,

Reminder Subject: TALK: And the Bayesians and the frequentists shall lie down together...

Title: "And the Bayesians and the frequentists shall lie down together..."

(What a CSAIL grad student moonlighting as a reporter learned about statistics)

Abstract: In 2007, an academic cardiologist downloaded 42 medical studies from the Web site of drug giant GlaxoSmithKline, combined them in a meta-analysis, and found that the world's best-selling diabetes drug caused heart attacks. GSK lost about $12 billion in sales and market value. But a different way to analyze the same data -- a "Bayesian" way -- finds that the drug actually reduces heart attacks. Or does it?

We often hear of this conflict, between Bayesian and "frequentist" statistics. But much of the conflict is misguided. Viewed formally, on the same axes, the two schools of statistics turn out to share a tight symmetry. Criticisms of each can be transformed into a corresponding criticism of the other.

I'll also show results from a new numerical algorithm that calculates the performance of "exact" hypothesis tests that hadn't previously been tractable to characterize. This algorithm has found unexpected behavior in the best such methods to date (calculated by tools like StatXact), and suggests a path forward that borrows from digital filter design.

Bio: Keith Winstein is a graduate student in CSAIL, advised by Hari Balakrishnan. From 2007 to 2010, he worked as a staff reporter at The Wall Street Journal, covering science and medicine.

Research Areas:

Impact Areas:

This event is not part of a series.

Created by Keith Winstein Email at Sunday, October 13, 2013 at 5:32 PM.